If I hadn’t done it myself, I would not have believed it possible.
When nonprofit boards undertake to improve their governance, it is typically a lengthy process, requiring a year or more of conversations, committee debates and board actions. But what if the board does not have an abundance of time – could a governance makeover be completed in, say, 28 hours?
That was the challenge I recently faced. A board I was working with underwent a significant change in its decades-long relationship with its agency’s sponsor and wanted to bring its governance structure up to modern “best practices” after laboring under a structure in place since the beginning of the relationship. There were some big questions the board needed to address about the agency’s future. Still, they realized that developing and implementing a comprehensive and effective strategic plan addressing those challenges might be impossible without an effective governance structure. They recognized not only the need to change, but also the need to do it fast. Rather than the typical 12-month-long governance project, they wanted to achieve the same result over a day and a half board retreat. It became a three-step process.
Day One- AM: Educate.
One of Northampton Advisors’ guiding principles for improving governance is that most nonprofit directors lack the knowledge and experience to be effective. Among all their knowledge deficits, the most problematic is that they often do not understand their role.
Directors are not cheerleaders or blind enablers for management. They are leaders, with well-defined responsibilities, and they are ultimately accountable for the success or failure of their program. No progress can occur until they understand their job, so that is where the weekend starts.

Day One- PM: Self-Reflection.
It has been my experience that nonprofit directors often know the weaknesses of their governance processes – or at least they know the symptoms that point to the underlying problems. So armed with the realization that they are the leaders who can bring positive change, the directors in the second session engage in a structured discussion that challenges the board to look at its governance activities and compare them to best practices commonly found in well-functioning governing bodies.

Here, the questions need to seek out objective facts, not:
“Does your board do a good job at financial oversight?”
But rather something more specific:
“At least once a year, does your board meet with your external auditor without management present?”
As the answers to these questions are compiled and assessed, the board will begin to develop a work plan for addressing the identified deficits, with the solutions often supplied by the questions:
“So, let’s start meeting with the auditor.”
Problem defined. Solution adopted.

Day Two: Commit to Change
How do you turn a “nice” board retreat into a “great” one?
This way: If, at the end of the meeting, the board has committed to an action plan to implement a list of well-defined changes to improve governance.
Day Two is when the magic happens, and the magician is the retreat leader. If the governance weaknesses are apparent to the directors, they should be glaringly evident to the retreat leader. The key to Day 2 is the development of a series of ten to twenty recommendations that can be presented to the board for discussion and endorsement. The goal is for the recommendations to become a list of action items for implementation, instead of a list of future discussions.
Sounds too easy. What could go wrong?
Weak attendance. A common trait of weak boards is poor attendance. A board retreat must be attended by a majority of the board, or at least a large percentage of the most active members.
How do you get the best turnout?
Scheduling the retreat well in advance and considering the best venue. The best way to get the board thinking like a team might be to take them off-site to a hotel or conference center, where hours of hard discussion can be balanced against a time to interact socially.
If an off-site overnight is not in the cards, then holding the meeting in a private and comfortable space also works well, even if it is within the four walls of the agency. What will not work, in my opinion, is a virtual retreat (for obvious reasons) or a retreat that spreads the discussion over weeks or months. To achieve clear results, the process needs the pressure of time.

Unresolved Grievances and a desire to revisit the past.
Sometimes board members come with baggage. A Governance Makeover must acknowledge past issues but not dwell on them. Unfortunately, for some board members, putting the past behind them can be a challenge.
Solution? It could be as simple as a whiteboard titled “Parking Lot”. Either you can break the flow of the day and confront the issue and have an unscheduled and likely futile discussion, or you can agree to talk about it at a different time and place. Hopefully, your new governance structure will better address future conflicts before they become festering grievances.
Lack of buy-in from Board Leadership and/or the CEO. Your Governance Initiative did not happen spontaneously. Hopefully, it was the product of a mutual agreement between the CEO and the board leadership that change was necessary. As any behavioral health practitioner will tell you, people change once they conclude that there is no alternative. So, before even considering a Governance Initiative, there needs to be a meeting of minds between the CEO and the Board Leadership.





