Our prior blog concluded that boards could benefit from an arbitrary limit on years of service. Term limits are a good way of helping a board remain vital and able to address the changing world in which its agency functions. Term limits can also address problematic directors whose behavior or conflicts have raised concerns that for whatever reason, could not be addressed by other measures.
Nonprofit corporations are designed to operate perpetually, and boards must understand that one of their primary responsibilities is replicating themselves and passing on the corporation’s leadership to a new generation of board members. To that end, a mechanism must be in place to say goodbye to even the best board members and welcome fresh talent into the organization.
The standard approach to addressing board stagnation is to limit the number of years directors can serve, often expressed in the number of successive terms to which they can be elected.
The “standard approach” has detractors; even many supporters would add exceptions and workarounds. This blog is focused on responding to some of those.
A General Objection- If we keep retiring board members, we’ll be forced to spend most of our time recruiting their replacements, and what’s to say their replacements will be as committed as the people who are leaving?
Yes, that’s right. Organizations that have turnover on their boards do need to have a much more aggressive attitude about recruitment. But if you agree that a board should be composed of a variety of people with various skills and viewpoints, turnover allows you to work to continuously fill in those gaps—even as your needs evolve. Your Nominating Committee should identify those needs and have a list of qualified candidates ready when a vacancy occurs. (More about the work of the Nominating Committee in a future blog.)
And what if the new directors are not as good as the departing ones? That, friends, is entirely under your control. Your board will be only as good as your nominating and onboarding process.
We have an excellent board, many of whom have served for twenty or more years. If we imposed term limits, most of them would be gone.
Transitioning to a limitation on years of service could immediately impact the board, perhaps even pushing out many directors who will be asked to pass the required bylaw amendment. In my legislative years, we addressed this type of problem with a Grandfather Clause—those directly affected would be given some grace period. A new limitation on board service could apply to all new directors but allow current directors to remain on the board for up to eight more years (for example) regardless of their prior service.
Term limits won’t work for our board. We have no problem recruiting people, but most new directors resign before the end of their first term. We are always left with just a few loyal, long-term members.
I agree! It appears you have a bigger problem to deal with before you consider term limits. Even without knowing your specific circumstances, I know that one or a combination of three things has occurred:
- Your recruitment process is broken.
- You have little or no onboarding procedures.
- You have a governance system that is totally broken.
The good news is that you are still getting people willing to serve; the bad news is that something is driving away new board members. You need an honest assessment of your situation, and interviewing those departing directors could be very helpful. More than likely, you already know what they are going to say. These are harsh words, but if you don’t fix the problem, your agency is likely doomed.
We have tried hard to recruit new board members but have been unsuccessful. We are a small agency with a narrow mission without the “appeal” of a university, major hospital or nationally recognized charity. With no “pool” of willing candidates, if we had term limits, we would have no board.
Often, boards get hung up trying to recruit directors from the same general demographic categories as the current board. Friends usually recruit friends. Sometimes, homogeneous boards fear that they could lose control by “widening the circle” and opening themselves to new voices. Good recruiting requires boards to think outside the box and look for candidates not typical of current directors – people from new neighborhoods, different ethnic backgrounds, or underrepresented professions. Nominating Committees should seek out organizations that train people to be volunteer board members, such as chambers of commerce or local community colleges. Many businesses encourage their employees to be active in the community. A frequently overlooked group of potential directors are the people the charity is serving, including those currently being served, formerly served or their parents, spouses or friends. Boards sometimes feel people who have had direct experience with the charity can come with an agenda or tend to be too much of an advocate for those served. On the other hand, they would come to the board with first-hand knowledge of the agency.
We now have term limits, but what do we do with all these departing directors?
Completing 12, 15 or 20 years of continuous service on a nonprofit board of directors is a true accomplishment worthy of a grand celebration. A party, a board resolution, a commemorative plaque or even the naming of a space in honor of the retiring director are good ways to recognize the service.
Another helpful tool to honor long-tenured board members and provide a mechanism to soften their transition off the board would be to elect them director emeritus. Often specifically allowed under bylaws, a director emeritus holds an honorary position, is not a board member, has no vote, and is not counted for the quorum. This is an excellent way to address directors who retire and move out of the community or whose participation has been reduced due to illness or other issues.
We are moving to adopt term limits, but can’t we make an exception for this one individual whose departure would have a significant impact?
Yes, there is often one special director, The Founder, The Major Donor, or Henry, who has been a director for as long as anyone can remember. Those do create unique challenges, and we will discuss them in our next blog. We will also discuss a potential “workaround” and the one instance where term limits must always be enforced.





